Steering Column

Gibson said:
These days, why does anyone use weld-on QRs anyway?

Safer and cheaper.
Click to expand...


I've heard of several situations where welds have broken on QRs.

But.......... in my car i've been running the stock wheel because they don't make a QR for it and i'm not convinced welding on the steering column is legal.......
 
I don't know if it is legal or not, haven't studied it yet as I will probably go with the stock wheel at first, I was just answering the question "why weld?"

A good weld is stronger than bolts, and cheaper and easier than buying or fabbing adapter plates.
 
Gibson said:
Safer and cheaper....A good weld is stronger than bolts...
Click to expand...
You're wrong in both regards, in context. You're arguably "right" that it's cheaper. Though most QRs cost about $50, so I'm not sure how much money you'd save versus time and risk.

JLawton said:
I've heard of several situations where welds have broken on QRs.
Click to expand...
I (as a tech inspector) have personally seen where the shaft broke as a result of a weld-on QR. Steering shafts are made of tempered steel, and by welding on them you are weakening them. Further, the one that I saw failed along the threads where the initial wheel was bolted on, due to forces in that area that it was never designed to handle (those threads are to keep a wheel from moving longitudinally along the shaft, not to resist bending loads. May as well have cut a notch in the shaft and labeled it "break here").

And arguing that a weld is strong than a bolt is...can I call it "ignorant" in the true sense of the word without unintended insult? The "forces" that a steering wheel are subjected to have nothing at all to do with bolting versus welding, as the bolts are only there to keep the wheels from sliding off the splines (which, by the way, you'd be bypassing. Which do you think is stronger in torsion: a questionable weld on a tempered shaft, or splines?)

But, to the rules question at hand.

You cannot remove or modify anything to install a steering wheel quick release. In point of fact, steering wheel quick releases aren't even explicitly allowed in the rules. However, "steering wheels can be replaced" thus the QR is technically a part of your replacement steering wheel.

Thus within the scope of the IT rules, replacement of parts do not allow modifications of other parts to install them. As such, the original sentence stands: nothing else can be removed or modified to install them.

i'm not convinced welding on the steering column is legal.......
Click to expand...
Neither am I, but we've gone through this argument before, and pretty much decided to let this sleeping dog lie...

http://www.improvedtouring.com/forums/showthread.php?t=18582
http://www.improvedtouring.com/forums/showthread.php?t=20198
http://www.improvedtouring.com/forums/showthread.php?t=15677
 
And arguing that a weld is strong than a bolt is...can I call it "ignorant" in the true sense of the word without unintended insult?

Absolutely. Not willing to concede the point without further investigation, but that implies obvious ignorance on my part, doesn't it? As long as we all remember than ignorance is fixable, I am cool with it.

I would put a little smiley deal here but I have hated those fucking things since I saw the first one in the sixties.
 
Nice links Jim.

But stack those pieces together and the steering wheel may land up in your chest.

Probably the reason for the original question.
 
joeg said:
Nice links Jim.

But stack those pieces together and the steering wheel may land up in your chest.

Probably the reason for the original question.
Click to expand...

those pieces are pretty "short", and just use a low dish wheel.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I took a closer look at our F Prod car today and Greg is right, I was ignorant. The welds I remembered were on an adapter, not the shaft.
 
Quick Way

Wow!!! An adapter bolted to another adapter which is bolted to another ect,ect,ect!!!!! I'd take a weld any day over that. And if they aren't legal, why are they allowed?
 
dick elliott said:
And if they aren't legal, why are they allowed?
Click to expand...
Not sure what that means. Things that are legal are allowed. Things that are not legal are not allowed.

It could be argued that you can weld something onto the end of the stock steering shaft. I don't see how anyone can argue that you can remove any of the stock shaft (which was the original question.)
 
joeg said:
Nice links Jim.

But stack those pieces together and the steering wheel may land up in your chest.

Probably the reason for the original question.
Click to expand...

For my Honda, I used a Momo bolt-on adapter and then an LTB Quick Release. It adds about 6" to the shaft length but I'm using a low-dish wheel in place of the factory unit. The end result is a wheel maybe 3" closer to the driver. In my case this is good b/c I can actually move my seat back far enough to give some extra leg room. :)

Christian
 
Have to disagree with Greg here. Steering shafts are not tempered really, they are case hardened for wear and the inner 95% is soft. RB 44-48 on a Mazda. A proper filler rod with a tig on the large diameter of the shaft is just as strong as any adapter. Control the heat and do not weld to the small threaded area. But then I might be ignorant as well.:026:

PS. If you have to ask on this forum how to weld it please take it to a professional so you don't end up holding a wheel with no car attached.
 
Last edited:
seckerich said:
But then I might be ignorant as well.:026:
Click to expand...
Nah, I'll defer to you on that, as I'm only half-sure on the process. However, I am sure they're heat-treated in some way and that improper welding can affect that, and I am very confident that welding on parts to them is neither a good idea nor compliant to the rules (as I described above and in those other linked threads.)

But, it's not one of those "areas" that's worth getting all riled up about (unless you're a stickler for rules as we tend to be...) - GA
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top